Articles 45-52

The 7 Rules That Determining Motion After Collision

The rules for determining how much the motion of each body is changed because of the collision of other bodies

Rene Descartes Rene Descartes
3 min read

45. The rules for determining how much the motion of each body is changed because of the collision of other bodies

Collisions with other bodies cause bodies to:

  • increase or decrease their motions, or
  • turn elsewhere

In order to calculate such changes, we only need to:

  • subtract the amount of force in each, either to move or to resist motion, and
  • establish for certain that which is stronger always achieves its effect.

This could easily be deduced by calculation if:

  • only 2 bodies encountered each other mutually
  • they were perfectly hard, and separated from all others.
    • In this way, their motions were not impeded by any other surrounding bodies, nor assisted.

They then would follow the following rules.

46. Rule 1

Assume Body B and C, were perfectly equal and moving at equal speeds. B is moving from right to left, and C from left to right.

CB1

When they encountered each other, they would be reflected and then continue to move, B to the right, and C to the left, without any loss of their speed.

47. Rule 2

If B were just slightly larger than C, then only C would be reflected. Both would move to the left with the same speed.

CB2

48. Rule 3

If they were equal in mass, but B moved slightly faster than C, they would both continue moving to the left. Some of B’s excess speed would be transferred to C.

CB3

If:

  • B had 6 units of speed
  • C had 4 units

After the collision, each would move to the left with 5 units of speed.

49. Rule 4

Assume body C were completely at rest and slightly larger than B. No matter how fast B moved towards C, it would never move C.

Instead, it would be repelled by C in the opposite direction.

CB4

This is because a stationary body resists high velocity more than low velocity, in proportion to the excess of one over the other.

Therefore, the force in C to resist would always be greater than in B to propel.

50. Rule 5

Assume that body C were stationary and smaller than B.

No matter how slowly B moved towards C, it would move C with it, transferring a portion of its own motion to it, so that both would subsequently move at the same speed.

CB5

Specifically, if B were twice as large as C, it would transfer to C 1/3 of its motion.

This is because that 1/3 would move the body C as quickly as the remaining 2/3 would move the body B, which is twice as large.

So, after B had encountered C, it would move 1/3 slower than before. It would take the same amount of time to move through a space of 2 feet as it did before to move through a space of 3 feet.

Similarly, if B were 3 times larger than C, it would transfer to C 1/4 of its motion, and so on for the rest.

51. Rule 6

If the mass of stationary body C were precisely equal to that of the moving body B, when B approached C with 4 units of speed, it would:

  • transfer 1 unit of speed to C
  • be reflected with the remaining 3 units in the opposite direction.
CB6

52. Rule 7

Assume B and C were moving towards the same direction.

  • C was moving slower, with B eventually catching up to it
  • C were larger than B
  • The speed of B was greater than the excess of size in C

Then B would transfer just enough of its motion to C so that both would subsequently move at the same speed and direction.

CB7

However, if the excess of speed in B were less than the excess of size in C, then B would be reflected in the opposite direction and retain all of its motion.

These excesses are calculated as follows:

  • If C were twice as large as B and B did not move twice as fast as C, it would not propel C but would be reflected in the opposite direction.
  • If it moved more than twice as fast, it would propel C.

For instance, if C had only 2 units of speed and B had 5, subtracting 2 units from B would transfer only 1 unit to C.

This would make both bodies move with 3 units of speed thereafter. This is because C is twice as large as B.

This would result in both bodies, B and C, moving with 3 units of speed.

This reasoning applies similarly to other cases.

Leave a Comment